All In One SEO Pack is the oldest WordPress SEO plugin. That alone should tell you something about the plugin and that is the fact that if a company has been around this long then they're doing something right. Although we get drawn to new and shiny plugins, a plugin like All In One SEO Pack can and will give you the similar level of optimization. All In One SEO Pack has all the settings in one page which may seem like a lot if you like things nicely organized. Others find this type of page better to navigate because everything is on the same page.
Please let us know if we have missed anything in the comments section.